Obama Admin Rejects Timeout for Natural Gas Drilling in N.Y., Pa.

The Obama administration has decided against pressing for a temporary halt to Marcellus Shale drilling in Pennsylvania and New York, a key federal official said.

Brig. Gen. Peter “Duke” DeLuca, commander of the North Atlantic Division of the Army Corps of Engineers, last week declined a request from Rep. Maurice Hinchey (D-N.Y.) to use the federal government’s vote on the Delaware River Basin Commission (DRBC) to seek a temporary ban on gas production in the Delaware watershed.

Hinchey wants drilling there to wait until the commission completes a “cumulative impact statement,” but DeLuca said that could delay drilling for years…

…Hinchey wrote DeLuca on Sept. 9, saying he was alarmed that the DRBC is preparing to finish regulations — which would allow production to start — this year, before a cumulative impact study could even start. He asked DeLuca to use his seat on the commission to advocate for blocking development until after the study is done.

As I stated in my prior correspondence to the Commission, I believe it is critical that the DRBC complete a comprehensive impact study of the potential impacts of tens of thousands of new natural gas wells throughout the Basin prior to releasing gas drilling regulations or permitting any individual projects. We need to examine and fully understand the risks to the Delaware River’s Special Protection Waters from land use disturbance and water use in all phases of gas exploration and development from exploratory wells to distribution pipelines in order to lessen and mitigate those risks. I therefore urge you, as the federal government’s representative to the DRBC, to take necessary action to allow the cumulative impact study to take place prior to the adoption of DRBC regulations for natural gas exploration and drilling.

I appreciate your consideration and assistance in this matter. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you would like to discuss this concern in greater detail.
September 9, 2010. Hinchey Urges Federal Representative to DRBC to Require Agency to Conduct Cumulative Impact Study before Allowing Natural Gas Drilling to Move Forward

“It is difficult to understand how the DRBC can consider the release of gas drilling regulations without a comprehensive assessment of the possible impacts in the Delaware River Basin,” Hinchey wrote…

Environmentalists say DeLuca is wrong when he asserts that the DRBC must balance environmental concerns with economic development. Jill Wiener, a leader of an upstate New York group called Catskills Citizens for Safe Energy, said the commission’s mandate is to protect water quality.

“They owe their fealty to the river and the people of the basin,” Wiener said, “not the economic health of a few leaseholders and multinational corporations.”

From left to right: Maurice Hinchey, Walter Hang, Dan Lamb (2010). Courtesy of Toxics Targeting

But industry officials say DeLuca was correct to reject Hinchey’s request.

“Just to be clear here, Hinchey was trying to use a federal agency to direct the actions of a regional water board for the purposes of preventing the development of natural gas in a state where he doesn’t even live,” said Chris Tucker, spokesman for Energy in Depth, a group of independent drillers. “Next thing you know, he’ll be ordering the Army Corps to build levees around our well sites in Wyoming.”